Plastic Bags Case Study - 1358 Words

1. How strong is the evidence to support Dr. Splinter’s arguments in favor of the plastic bag ban, and what are the limitations of this evidence? Specific claims are that litter will be noticeably reduced, the drainage system will be less prone to clogging, utilization of the landfill will be reduced, and there will be fewer environmental hazards for endangered wildlife. What specific information in the documents do you find compelling and why? Be sure to cite the information in the documents as well as any other factors you considered that led you to this conclusion. Dr. Splinter makes a strong argument that plastic bags should be banned. According to the 2011 report by the City of San Jose, their ban of plastic bags ended up in a†¦show more content†¦There was a reduction of over 1600 plastic bags ending up in the local waterways, with plastic bags being 3.2% of all litter found in the waterways, and they were previously 8.2% in 2011. (SanJoseCA.gov, 2012). The ban on plastic bags seemed to greatly affect the city in a positive way and did not appear to have a negative effect at all, despite protests by some locals and business owners. Of course, there are adjustments with any change in policy or law, but the plastic bag ban can be one that can help the nature preserve, as well as the local area. Essentially costs may go up initially, but in the long run, the city will save money in a variety of ways while helping to keep wildlife safe, and waterways cleaner. Dr. Splinter s observation that a ban is necessary is a solid argument and is one that the city should adopt. 2. How strong is the evidence for Mr. Shredder’s arguments against the plastic bag ban, and what are the limitations of this evidence? Specific arguments are that local businesses will lose sales, empirical evidence does not indicate that the projected benefits of plastic bag bans will materialize, the cost of purchasing reusable bags adversely impacts the poor, and the same projected benefits of the plastic bag ban can be achieved by stronger recycling efforts. What specific information in theShow MoreRelatedNo Plastic Bag Day Research Proposal1689 Words   |  7 Pagesto   practice green concept due to customer pressure and government regulation. Thus in this case, government becomes a power stakeholder which enforces the company to practice green concept through no plastic bag day . No plastic bag day was first started at the state of Penang on 1 July 2009 every Monday, before it was extended to Tuesdays and Wednesdays as well from Jan 2. To promote the â€Å"No Plastic Bag Day† ruling, the state distributed 500,000 brochures to create public awareness besides erectingRead MorePlastic Bags And Its Effects On The Universe851 Words   |  4 PagesNowadays, the use of plastic bags has increased. It can be seemed that plastic bags are really needed by everyone especially for their daily life. Comparing to the past in the early 1950s when people still used the paper bags instead of plastic bags. Literally, plastic bags are very useful for human, but at the same time it is also bring disadvantages. Plastic is made from fossil fuel sources, such as natural gas and petroleum. It is not biodegradable and it will always exist. This is why the excessiveRead MorePlastic Bags And Its Effects On The Choice996 Words   |  4 Pages Simply choosing plastic over paper as a convenience is no excuse for discounting the harmful effects of the choice. Some persons reading this will be too young to remember when grocery stores first started asking their patrons if they would prefer the new convenient plastic bags or the old paper sacks in which to carry their groceries. It seemed a simple enough question at the time. The question was merely inquiring of the patron their opinion of convenience. But what if the same exact questionRead MoreThe Impact Of Plastic Shopping Bags And Environmental Impact859 Words   |  4 PagesPlastic Shopping Bags Environmental Impact Disposable bags may seem convenient but have proven to be a huge source of pollution. According to research conducted by the Environmental Protection Agency, somewhere between five hundred billion and one trillion disposable bags are used each year around the world. Plastic bags, while only used for an average of about twelve minutes, remain in landfills, oceans, and other places for thousands of years. Plastic bags are created using fossil fuels andRead MoreEssay about Disposing Large Amounts of Waste1102 Words   |  5 PagesIn present-day societyï ¼Å'plastic packing are pervasive around the street ,causing a lot of problems . A study from Department of Enviroment,Food and Rural Affairs Annual Report(2008) shown that the amount of packaging waste reached approximately 10.7 million tonnes in the UK ,which has been deal with. It is obvious that the problems of waste are serious. In this essay I will analysis some problems caused by this phenomenon ,then propose some solutions and criticized them as well . Some problemsRead MoreAre Plastic Bags And The United Kingdom?1538 Words   |  7 Pagesfoul things they call plastic bags. Don’t believe it? That’s understandable. Not many people know the consequences of their actions; even the ones that killed thousands of sea animals and destroyed the marine environment. Anthony L. Andrady, author of q, has even stated that according to numerous surveys taken around the world consistently demonstrated that plastic materials make up 60-80% of marine debris. That little dolphin or penguin who accidently ingests that one plastic bag will die a slow deathRead MoreEssay On Plastic Pollution1722 Words   |  7 PagesPlastic pollution, it is a major killer in the worlds seas life, with over 30% of turtles worldwide and 90% of seabird species having ingested plastic debris that has contaminated their ecosystem1. One of the major contributors to this pollution is plastic bags. Each day Australians use over 10 million plastic bags, resultin g in 4 billion produced every year. An estimated 2.4 billion beverage containers and 1 billion lightweight plastic shopping bags are used in Queensland every year, ending upRead MoreTime To Say Goodbye to the Disposable Plastic Shopping Bag Essay1560 Words   |  7 Pagesnatural gas arent just used to produce energy, they also compose a dizzying spectrum of plastic products that we use hundreds of times a day. Consider the disposable plastic shopping bag that has become emblematic of our consumer culture. By some calculations the bag is â€Å"the single most ubiquitous consumer item on Earth, numbering in the trillions† (Lapidos). Americans alone discard some one hundred billion bags annually after trips home from stores, the â€Å"equivalent to dumping nearly 12 million barrelsRead MoreThe Effects Of Plastic Pollution On California1411 Words   |  6 Pages Plastic Pollution in California The beauty of California is slowly fading away and as environmentalists would say, â€Å"There was once a town in the heart of America where all life seemed to live in harmony with its surrounding† (Carson, 366). According to the findings revealed by research foundations in California, marine life is and has been in great danger as a result of plastic remains that accumulates in the Ocean. In his article Daniel Woods states, â€Å"Approximately eighty percent ofRead MoreA Study On Indiana State University1106 Words   |  5 PagesHolly Black Dr. Speer 23 March 2015 Indiana State University Garbology Study of Indiana State Students Abstract Garbology can be beneficial when studying the waste of a certain group of people. I studied the trash of two different Indiana State students; the first was an environmentally aware student that lives off campus, while the second was a student who has no environmental concern. First, I asked them to complete a survey on their use of waste from Global Footprint Network, this would calculate